The Saints’ Quarterback Quandary: A Legacy of Oversight

When Drew Brees hung up his cleats in 2021, the New Orleans Saints faced an inevitable question: who would lead them next? Yet, as the years have unfolded, it’s become evident that the Saints never truly sought an answer.

The Illusion of Stability

For over a decade, Brees was the cornerstone of the franchise, leading them to numerous playoff appearances and a Super Bowl victory. His retirement should have been a catalyst for succession planning. Instead, the Saints seemed content to let the future unfold organically, a gamble that has yet to pay off.

A Series of Missed Opportunities

In the years following Brees’ departure, the Saints had opportunities to draft a successor. However, they consistently opted for short-term solutions, bringing in quarterbacks like Jameis Winston and Taysom Hill, neither of whom proved to be the long-term answer. The franchise’s reluctance to invest in a future quarterback has left them in a perpetual state of uncertainty.

The Derek Carr Gamble

In an attempt to stabilize the position, the Saints signed Derek Carr to a four-year, $150 million contract. However, Carr’s tenure was short-lived, as he retired due to shoulder injuries, leaving the team once again searching for a leader. This move underscores the franchise’s ongoing struggle to find a lasting solution at quarterback.

Looking Ahead: A New Direction?

With the 2025 season approaching, the Saints are at a crossroads. Speculation has arisen about the possibility of tanking for a high draft pick to select a future quarterback. While this strategy may seem prudent, it raises questions about the franchise’s commitment to winning in the immediate future.

As the Saints navigate this challenging period, one must wonder: will they ever find a quarterback who can fill the void left by Brees, or are they doomed to wander in this quarterback purgatory indefinitely?