The MVP Paradox: Haliburton’s Historic Run vs. SGA’s Legacy

In the 2025 NBA Finals, Tyrese Haliburton has delivered clutch performances, including a game-winning shot in Game 1 and a near triple-double in Game 3, leading the Pacers to a 2-1 series lead. Despite his heroics, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander of the Thunder remains the favorite for Finals MVP, highlighting the paradox of individual brilliance versus team success.

Kirsten CollinsJune 12, 20251 Mins read207

NBA Finals MVP rankings, odds: History on Tyrese Haliburton's side, but SGA still remains the favorite

Imagn Images

A New Hero Emerges

With a calm demeanor and a sharp basketball IQ, Tyrese Haliburton has captivated the NBA world. In Game 1 of the 2025 Finals, he delivered a buzzer-beating shot, marking the latest game-winner in an NBA Finals since Michael Jordan’s iconic 1997 moment. ESPN’s Brian Windhorst lauded Haliburton’s clutch performances, stating, “Haliburton is unequivocally having the greatest run of clutch shooting we have seen in the history of the sport.”

The MVP Paradox

Despite Haliburton’s heroics, the MVP award often favors the player from the winning team. Historically, only one player from a losing team has won the Finals MVP: Jerry West in 1969. As the Pacers lead the series 2-1, Haliburton’s chances hinge on Indiana securing the championship.

SGA’s Legacy

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, the Thunder’s star, remains the favorite for Finals MVP. His consistent scoring and leadership have been pivotal for Oklahoma City. However, his candidacy is challenged by Haliburton’s standout performances, raising questions about the criteria for the MVP award.

A Defining Moment

As the series progresses, the debate intensifies: Will Haliburton’s individual brilliance be enough to sway the MVP vote, or will team success tip the scales in favor of Gilgeous-Alexander? The answer may redefine the narrative of the 2025 NBA Finals.